Yes, the batch file is written to specifically copy my important data files, and mailboxes to another location, on a physicall separate hard drive.
What I'm saying is this: By creatively partitioning, I can make my ghost images of each drive, and store them elsewhere. (CDRW) If my main drive fails, I can restore everything, the OS, the apps, the data, I mean everything, in minutes, rather than hours, or even days. I could take a lightening strike, and repair the hardware, and be restored in minutes, up and running, surfing, whatever. There is simply no faster and better way to recover from a disaster.
Drive sizes are getting to the point of being ridiculous. There is now a 100 gig drive available. The sad truth is, there are no really good hardware/software backup solutions available at affordable prices for large volumes of data. There are DLT tape drives, used primarily for backing up servers. These cost several grand, and tapes are 80 bucks apiece. Of course, they can hold upto 80 gig compressed.
Large, unorganized drives are harder to maintain than, several smaller, task specific partitions.
Every solution I have heard proposed here, is piecemeal at best, chock full of pitfalls. I must admit, any backup scheme is better then none at all. Some are better than others.
I realize you had a bad experience, but consider this. Just like some homeowners have had bad experiences with powerwashers, even they can be won over into the fold of satisfied customers. Go find yourself a "good" computer guy locally. You will then be a satisfied customer as well.