Good Morning Gentlemen,
Myself, I have to agree with Johnny on this. The main purpose of using sodium hydroxide is to loosen this crud up to be able to remove it without doing damage to the wood. If this deck has never had any finish applied to it then the UV damage has already been done so the chances of getting the fuzzies is already extream, regardless of what cleaning process or cleaner you use.
I just bid a job for 1.6 million on a ski lodge in Eastern Oregon. This lodge has had nothing on it for 24 years and has a black crust from UV damage. They tried the bleach and everything else they could think of to remove this crust but nothing worked. I tested with Industrial Strip-X mixed 1 to 1 with about 45 minute dwell time, scrubed with a stiff bruse and re-applied more product. I gave the second application another 45 minutes dwell time and power washed it off. Did I get the fuzzies, sure did but I knew I would before I tested. The substrate was so degraded from UV I knew that no matter what I used, I would get the fuzzies. Did I get the job, won't know till next year.
I'm not sure what is meant by the stastement made above about this burning up the wood. I've never seen sodium hydroxide "burn wood before". Maybe some of your home made stuff might do this but I've never seen Industrial Strip-X burn wood. I have done several jobs where someone used bleach and burnt the wood and I contracted to go in and repair them.
Is sodium hydroxide over kill, some people might think so. Personally, I don't like doing rework and I want to give my clients the best job possible. If it takes over kill to do this, then so be it. I usally overkill all my jobs anyway.
Jim Bilyeu
Exterior Woodcare